Natural Fibers vs Recycled Plastic — Honest Pros and Cons

Natural Fibers vs Recycled Plastic: Honest Pros and Cons


A plastic bottle becomes a legging. A cotton flower becomes a t-shirt. Both are sold as "sustainable". On the mat, against warm skin, they do not feel the same, and they do not end the same way either.

Sustainable clothing is a big topic in fashion today, as more and more people become aware of the environmental impact of what they wear. Two families of fabrics are often presented as the responsible choice: natural fibers and recycled plastic fabrics. In this article we look honestly at the pros and cons of each, to help you choose with clarity.

Natural fibers

Natural fibers come from plants or animals: cotton, linen, hemp, wool, silk. Fibers made from plant cellulose, such as bamboo viscose, are close cousins. They are generally considered more environmentally friendly than synthetic fibers because they are biodegradable and, when grown organically, can be produced with fewer harmful chemicals.

Sohang yoga top and Sohang yoga pants in beige organic cotton
Sohang top and pants in beige, brushed organic cotton jersey.

Pros of natural fibers

  • Biodegradable: natural fibers break down over time and can return to the soil, instead of piling up in landfills.
  • Renewable: they grow back each season, while synthetic fibers come from non-renewable resources such as oil.
  • Durable: well-made cotton jersey, linen and wool can last for many years with proper care.
  • Comfortable: many people find natural fibers more pleasant to wear. They breathe, absorb moisture and feel softer on the skin.
  • No microplastics: when you wash them, the tiny fibers they release are not plastic.

Cons of natural fibers

  • More expensive: natural fibers, especially organic ones, cost more to produce, so garments made from them often cost more to buy.
  • Sensitive to stains: some fibers, such as wool and silk, stain more easily and are harder to clean.
  • Require more care: they can shrink or lose their shape if washed too hot or tumble dried. Our care guide for natural fiber yoga clothes shows how simple it can be.
  • Resource use: conventional cotton needs a lot of water and pesticides. Organic farming reduces the chemical part, which is why the choice of an organic fiber matters.

Recycled plastic fabrics

Recycled plastic fabrics are made from plastic bottles or other plastic waste, melted and spun into new polyester or nylon fibers. The process is often called "upcycling", because it gives discarded plastic a second life.

Pros of recycled plastic fabrics

  • Reduces waste: they give a use to plastic that might otherwise end up in landfills or in the ocean.
  • Durable: recycled polyester is strong and can last for many years.
  • Water-resistant: some recycled plastic fabrics repel water, which makes them useful for outdoor clothing.
  • Less virgin oil: they reduce the need to extract new petroleum for new synthetic fibers.

Cons of recycled plastic fabrics

  • Still synthetic: recycled plastic is still plastic. It is not biodegradable and can take hundreds of years to break down.
  • Microplastics: synthetic fabrics shed microfibers with every wash, which end up in rivers and seas.
  • Energy to produce: collecting, cleaning, melting and spinning plastic requires energy, so recycled fabrics also have a carbon footprint.
  • Hard to recycle again: once blended with elastane and dyed, a garment is rarely recycled a second time. The loop often ends after one round.
  • Less breathable: on the skin, especially during long or warm practice, synthetic fabrics tend to hold heat and moisture.

In conclusion

Both natural fibers and recycled plastic fabrics have their pros and cons. Natural fibers are biodegradable, renewable and breathable, but they cost more and ask for a little more care. Recycled plastic fabrics give plastic waste a second life, but they remain synthetic, shed microplastics and need energy to produce. The best choice depends on what you value and on how you will use the garment.

Where we stand at Breath of Fire

For a raincoat, recycled polyester can make sense. For yoga, where the body opens, warms up and breathes for an hour or more, we chose natural fibers. Since 2009 we have worked only with organic cotton and bamboo viscose, with a small share of elastane for stretch. We explain this choice in detail in why we only use organic cotton and bamboo viscose, and the comfort side in the benefits of natural fibers in yoga clothing.

Ankaa straight leg yoga pants in khaki with Maia tank top in mercerized organic cotton
Ankaa pants in khaki and Maia tank top, mercerized organic cotton jersey.

Discover our fabrics on the our fabrics page, or browse the women's collection and the men's collection.

Frequently asked questions

Is recycled polyester better than organic cotton?

Not in every way. Recycled polyester reuses plastic waste, but it is still plastic: it sheds microfibers and does not biodegrade. Organic cotton is renewable, biodegradable and free of synthetic pesticides. For clothing worn close to the skin during practice, we prefer organic cotton.

Do natural fibers shed microplastics?

No. All fabrics release some fibers when washed, but cotton, linen or viscose fibers are not plastic and can break down in nature. The small share of elastane in a stretch jersey is synthetic, which is one more reason to wash gently and less often.

How can I make any garment more sustainable?

Wear it often and for a long time. Wash at low temperature, air dry, repair small holes. The most sustainable garment is the one you already own and love.

Choose what can return to the earth.